Vol. 30 No. 3 (2022)

SOME CHALLENGES IN PATIENTS’ RIGHTS PROTECTION IN VIETNAMESE MEDICAL LAW

Authors

  • Nguyen Thi Bao Anh, Tran Khac Qui

Keywords:

Medical law, medical malpractice, patients’ rights protection, public and private sectors

Abstract

In Vietnam, the medical legislation termed “Law on Medical Examination and Treatment” does not link strongly with Civil Law, Criminal Law, and Administrative Law to protect patients. To a large extent, all of these laws don’t mention the patients’ rights, while ironically, people assume that the medical, legal framework provides strong protection. To their (patients) dismay, it usually becomes impractical to solve suits legally whenever medical malpractice occurs. There are alarming numbers of cases of patients’ rights violations year by year due to medical unprofessionalism and weak, overlapping, and contradictory medical law. This has caused mistrust of the medical system leading to the out-flux of Vietnamese patients to neighboring countries to seek treatment. As the violation of the patients’ rights occurs, how does the available medical legislation play its role? It’s widely documented that there are rampant malpractices- misdiagnosis and wrong treatment caused by non-adherence to medical ethics and the gross shortcomings in the medical legal system. Some medical malpractices are criminalized passively only through administrative penalties at the expense of the patients' dignity. This paper will provide a detailed analysis of the above issues: Vietnamese medical law, its strength and shortcomings, medical malpractices, and how the practitioners live with it and suggest some benchmarks to align the medical law comparatively to other developing or developed countries economies.

References


    AFP, April 18th, 2014, the Vietnam measles outbreak kills more than 100 people, mostly children. Retrieved from http://www.smh.com.au/ Decree 66/2013/ND-CP about Regulations of basic wage for for officals and armed forces issued on June 27th 2013 Emily Jackson,Medical Law – Texts, Cases and materials,– Oxford University Press Ha My, BBC, July 10th 2013, Why do Vietnam’s patients bride their doctors? Retrieved from http://www.bbc.com/news/ Hong Hai,November 21th 2013, Hanoi was embarrassed to punish the doctor cause two young deaths. Retrieved from http://dantri.com.vn/ Law on Examinationd Treatment, 2009 Life and Law, The deaths of three injected the poison: scene faked http://www.doisongphapluat.com/ Lord Chielf Justice Coleridgein R v Instan (1983) 1 QB at 453 Masson and McCall Smith’s, Law and medical Ethics, Seventh Edition 2006, Oxford University Ministry of Health of Vietnam, Five – year Health Sector Development plan 2011 – 2015 THANHNIENNEWS, October 27th, 2012, Vietnam reports sixth maternity death in fortnight, October 27th 2012. October 22nd 2013 Nguyen Thuy, April 4th 2014, Thanh Hoa: Many pediatric doctors are deciplined. Retrieved from http://dantri.com.vn/ Tuoitre, October 22nd 2013, Vietnamese doctor throws customer's body into river. Retrieved from http://tuoitrenews.vn/ Thanh Quang, October 25th 2013, How are“Doctor is a beloved mom” now in Vietnam? Retrieved from http://www.rfa.org/vietnamese/ Trong Phu, July 29th 2005, Hai Phong: Disciplined 8 doctors delayed to treat the patient. Retrieved from http://www.ykhoa.net/index.htm Vo Xuan Son, April 5th 2014, Why is it difficult for a doctor becomes a virtuous mother? Retrieved from http://vnexpress.net/ Vietnam’s Parliament Meets on April 1st 2014 Vietnamnet, November 11th 2011; Doctors blunder in Can Tho hospital, remove both kidneys of the patient, http://www.vietnambreakingnews.com/ Vietnamnet, November 11th 2011; Doctors blunder in Can Tho hospital, remove both kidneys of the patient, http://www.vietnambreakingnews.com/

Downloads

Published

2022-11-24

How to Cite

Central European Management Journal, 30(3), Retrieved from https://journals.kozminskicem-j.com/index.php/pl_cemj.index.html

Issue

Section

Articles
Loading...